Back to articles

Tax penalty shootout: Who has the tax edge on Australian deals?

by Tony Nunes

Effective 01 July 2027, Australian resident individuals and trusts will move from the 50% capital gains tax (CGT) discount to an inflation-indexation model. Team Australia (a resident investor) and Team Offshore (a non-resident investor) face a penalty shootout under this new regime.

The ref blows the whistle:

1. CGT gains

While gains for Team Australia from July 2027 will be calculated on a “real gain” basis, effective tax rates can still reach 47%, with a minimum rate of 30% applying to indexed gains.

For a typical foreign investment in a technology, healthcare, services, or an industrial company that is not land-rich, a non-resident investor will often pay no Australian CGT on exit.

Goal to Team Offshore!

2. The ESVCLP/VCLP carry transition

Under the proposed transition to the new CGT regime, many holders of carried interests in traditional Australian venture capital structures (e.g. venture capital limited partnerships, or VCLPs, and early stage venture capital limited partnerships, or ESVCLPs) may struggle to establish a market value as of 30 June 2027, resulting in historical gains in these funds being taxed at 47%, instead of the anticipated 23.5%. 

The offshore investor has no such problem if the underlying shares are not investments in real property assets. 

Gooaaalll! 2–0.

3. The indexation residency trap

Under the new indexation framework, access to Consumer Price Index (CPI) uplift is linked to residency status. An Australian taxpayer who becomes a foreign resident, even briefly, can forfeit access to indexation benefits that would otherwise apply to long-term investments.

The result is unusual. An Australian who works overseas may lose a concession on Australian investments, while a foreign investor who never paid Australian tax may remain entirely outside Australia's CGT jurisdiction.

Team Offshore leads 3–0!

4. The expanded real property definition

From 01 October 2026, Australia significantly broadened its taxing rights across a wider range of infrastructure, energy, mining, and land-connected assets. The reform has substantially levelled the playing field for Australian investors in those sectors.

Team Australia scores its first goal, but is this new approach a good policy decision for attracting investment into Australia?

5. Investment structures

Australian super funds retain their 1/3 CGT discount and continue to pay a maximum effective CGT rate of approximately 10% under the new CGT regime.

A non-resident investing through a managed investment trust (MIT) or attribution managed investment trust (AMIT) that makes capital gains on real property assets pays a final Australian withholding tax ranging from 15% to 30%. No tax is paid on other capital gains.

Each side scores.

The final score: 4–2.

Under the new CGT regime, Australian capital investing in Australian businesses can face a materially higher tax burden than foreign capital investing alongside it. For non-resident investors this may make Australia increasingly attractive. Not because Australian assets have become cheaper, but because domestic capital will be competing with a tax handicap come July 2027.


Tony Nunes has over 25 years’ experience in providing tax advice to clients, especially on issues affecting cross-border transactions, acquisitions and restructures, and on all aspects of structuring the ownership and financing of corporations and their operations.

about 14 hours ago

Kelly+Partners Chartered Accountants