Back to articles

Lower middle market M&A: W&I insurance is coming your way

by Job Berns

Since the dawn of mergers and acquisitions, sellers and purchasers have been arguing over warranties and indemnifications. Luckily for them, the late 1980s provided a solution: warranty and indemnity (W&I) insurance policies. 

This enabled parties to insure the warranties and indemnifications granted by the seller, keeping the seller out of the line of fire – at least from risks covered by the policy. 

The start of W&I insurance

With Lloyd’s of London as one of the W&I pioneers, policies tended to be very expensive. On top of that, the underwriting would take weeks, and the exclusions were so strict that one would be left wondering what was actually covered in return for all those dollars, euros, or pounds spent. As a result, sellers and purchasers hardly used W&I insurance and simply accepted the extra legal fees for negotiating warranties and indemnifications.

W&I as a market practice 

Private equity marched into the M&A world in the early 2000s, and a new era for W&I insurance was introduced. Private equity firms buy, grow, and then sell companies, distributing the proceeds to their investors straight away. That model calls for a clean exit, which happens to be right up W&I insurance's alley. A PE seller has no interest in holding back part of the proceeds, either in years of exposure to warranty claims, or in leaving a couple of million in escrow “just in case”. 

W&I insurance took off, with many PE firms demanding it in their transactions. This led to its rapid progress in terms of price, terms, and underwriting conditions, ultimately leading to its broad adoption by sellers in the M&A market. Given their cost, however, these policies only made sense in deals of (higher) eight figures and up. 

Shift towards buy-side W&I

As the amounts at stake grew, purchasers started to take matters into their own hands. Instead of having the seller take care of the W&I insurance, purchasers took out policies, and negotiated a lower purchase price in return. This is particularly attractive when the seller stays on as a manager. The purchaser claims from the insurer rather than from its own manager, which protects the business relationship. 

Accessibility for lower middle market M&A

Fast forward to today. While deals worth eight figures or more were previously needed to make W&I profitable, the situation now is completely different. In mid-market M&A, insurance is by no means a rarity. In fact, even the lower middle market (deals starting at EUR 5 million) can now take advantage of W&I insurance, since premiums sometimes fall below 2% of the insured value and there are specialised providers offering W&I specifically for this market. 

For an entrepreneur selling their life's work, a clean exit is just as appealing as for a PE firm. So the next time warranties stall your negotiations, W&I insurance may be well worth a closer look, long before your deal reaches nine figures.


Job Berns is an attorney-at-law specialising in corporate litigation and M&A. Detail-oriented and committed, he goes the extra mile for clients. He advises on acquisitions, corporate housekeeping and shareholder disputes, combining thorough legal analysis with practical solutions.

about 14 hours ago

Poelmann van den Broek Attorneys-at-Law